Why Four "Ideal Weight" Formulas Give Four Different Numbers

There isn't one ideal weight formula -- there are at least four in common clinical use, and they don't agree with each other. Enter the same height and sex into the Devine, Robinson, Miller, and Hamwi formulas and you'll get four different numbers, sometimes several kilograms apart. That's not a bug in any one of them. It's a reminder that "ideal weight" was never meant to be the precise, personalized target it's often treated as.

Where these formulas actually came from

None of these were designed to tell healthy people what they should weigh. Hamwi's formula dates to 1964 and was built for quick bedside estimates in clinical nutrition. Devine's formula, from 1974, was created specifically to calculate drug dosages -- things like antibiotic or anesthetic dosing, where clinicians needed a fast approximation of lean body size rather than a patient's actual weight. Robinson (1983) and Miller (1983) came later as attempts to refine Devine's numbers against different patient data. All four were medical shortcuts first, fitness benchmarks second.

Same structure, different constants

Despite the different outputs, all four formulas work the same way: start with a baseline weight for someone 5 feet tall, then add a fixed amount for every inch of height above that, using separate constants for men and women. The only thing that changes between formulas is what those baseline and per-inch numbers are. Hamwi's increment per inch is higher than Miller's, for example, which is exactly why the same 5'10" input produces a lower number in one formula than another. They're not measuring different things -- they're just calibrated differently.

Why the same person gets different "ideal" weights

Here's the part that matters more than the formulas themselves: none of them account for anything except height and sex. No frame size, no muscle mass, no bone density, no body composition. A powerlifter and someone with very little muscle, at the same height, get handed the identical "ideal" number. That's fine for a rough dosing estimate in a hospital, where the alternative is no estimate at all -- but it's a poor fit for deciding what a healthy weight looks like for an actual individual.

This is also why these formulas and BMI don't always agree. BMI scales weight against height squared, not height linearly, and it returns a range rather than a single point. Compare an ideal-weight formula's single number against a BMI-based healthy range for the same person and you'll often see the formula's answer sitting near one edge of the range, or occasionally just outside it. Neither tool is "more correct" -- they're built on different math answering slightly different questions.

Treat the spread as the actual information

If you calculate your "ideal weight" four different ways and get four numbers spanning several kilograms, that spread is more useful than any single number in it. It tells you these formulas are population averages dressed up as precise targets. A result that falls somewhere in the middle of that range is a reasonable ballpark. A result that falls outside all four is worth paying attention to. But chasing the exact figure from any one formula -- especially one built in 1964 to dose medication, not to define fitness -- is asking more precision from the math than it was ever built to deliver.

The practical use case here isn't "hit this number." It's seeing how much these estimates can vary for your own height, so you don't anchor on whichever single formula you happened to Google first.

Run your own height through all four at once with the Ideal Weight Calculator, or check where your current weight falls on a standard range with the BMI Calculator.